• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Judy Ridgway

Olive Oil Quality, Taste and Flavour

  • Home
  • Books
  • Guest posts
  • Olive oil
  • Other oils
  • Recipes
  • About
  • Contact

Off the Shelf: September

8 September 2018 by Judy Ridgway

Olives ripening on the tree

Olives ripening on the tree

Here is another post in my new series looking at extra virgin olive oils taken at random from the market. I am very lucky to have samples of evoo sent to me from time to time direct from the producers and of course these oils are likely to be the very best they produce.  So I thought I would have a regular look at what is actually on retail sale in the shops and on dedicated websites.

This month I bought two supermarket oils, one own label and one branded, and one from Selfridges in London.  Two are blends of oils sourced on the international olive oil market and the other comes from Puglia in Italy.  They vary in price from £2.99 to £19.98 for a half litre.  None of them were particularly good, though the most expensive was probably the better oil.  I personally would not buy any of them.

Co-op own label extra virgin olive oil

  • This is a blend of oils from the European Union, unspecified
  • It is bottled in the UK for the Co-op
  • I could not find a “best before” date though the front label advised that it was on the back label
  • It is priced at £2.99 for 500ml (5.99 per litre)

This oil has quite a pleasant aroma of tropical fruits, melon and pineapple with a touch of lemon.  However, the flavour in the mouth is not at all what you might exect from the aromas.  It is a touch sickly and very bitter.

Carapelli Organice extra virgin olive oil

  • This is a blend of oils from the European Union and from non EU producing countries, unspecified
  • It is bottled in Italy by Casa Oleria Carapelli
  • The “best before” date is 06.2019
  • It is priced at £7.00 for 500ml (14.00 per litre)

This oil has a not unpleasant lightly stalky and woody aroma with some nuts.  In the mouth the flavours are light to start with and then some pepper comes in and some flavours which I find hard to describe.

Muraglia Peranzana from Selfridges

  • This comes from Puglia in the heel of Italy.
  • It is pressed soley from the Peranzana olive
  • The use by date is 27/06/19
  • It is priced at £9.99 for 250ml (£39.96 per litre)

This oil has a surprisingly light aroma though there is some spicy greenery, nuts and touch of citrus skins.  The flavours in the mouth are stronger with mixed leaves, stalks and nuts followed by really strong pepper which comes in before some bitter almond tones.  This is a very robust oil which is only just balanced.  I do not personally think that it is worth the money.  However, if you enjoy a peppery oil this is the one for you.

 

 

 

Filed Under: Olive oil

Previous Post: « SALAD DAYS
Next Post: Widening distribution for The Olive Oil Diet »

Primary Sidebar

Front cover of The Olive Oil Diet

The Olive Oil Diet
The best choice for a long and healthy life

My latest book, written with co-author Dr. Simon Poole, has just reached its third reprint. It is available from Waterstone's shops and online

IWFS Monograph

Around the World with Olive Oil
A look at quality, styles and flavour characteristics
This is a monograph for the International Food and Wine Society. It is available direct from the society

Categories

  • Books
  • Classes
  • Guest posts
  • Miscellaneous
  • My story
  • New Products
  • Olive oil
  • Other oils
  • Polyphenols
  • Recipes
  • specialist shop
  • Table olives
  • Tasting oil
  • Travel

Social Media

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Recent Posts

  • Look Younger, Live longer and …….
  • What to do with that aging oil?
  • Olive Oil Mini Classes 2025
  • Olive Oil Gin Martini
  • New way to solve the problem of finding the best olive oils in the shops

© 2016 - 2019 Judy Ridgway | All Rights Reserved | Website by Callia Web